PDA

View Full Version : Fear Itself Is a BLACKEST NIGHT Ripoff?



JxXxR
02-23-2011, 07:57 PM
Fear Itself and Blackest Night, A Saving Grace
A non-mainstream hero has his mythology expanded upon as an ancient enemy unleashes variants of the hero's signature weapon. No, this is not DC's hugely successful blockbuster Blackest Night, it is Marvel's upcoming event called Fear Itself.



DC (more specfically Geoff Johns) took Green Lantern and created a total of eight new Lantern Corps and wove a Lord of the Rings-esque mythology around the character, who beforehand was largely unknown to the general public. Now with his increased popularity and visibility, the Green Lantern has a movie to out this summer, as well as a few new books being added to his line (Emerald Warriors and Red Lantern Corps).
Marvel is clearly aiming to mimic that forumla for success. Usually big cross-over events involve all of the most popular characters gathering for an epic-scale battle, but after Johns wrote an event starring a B-list character who earned A-list dollars, that formula looks to be getting a change.

As can be understood from the initial press releases teasing the story, the God of Fear has been unleashed and his awakening has uncovered seven magical hammers on Earth, all of which must be weilded by someone who is deemed "worthy." And in the center of all this craziness is Thor. The story has taken obvious cues from Blackest Night. It's clear they replaced Nekron with the God of Fear, the rings with hammers, and Green Lantern with Thor. To even go one further, all of the Black Lanterns made every character confront their most tortured memories of those they lost. Marvel is taking a direct, more obvious route by making each character confront what they personally fear the most.

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-ocDdea9nddE/TWVDp6jbKII/AAAAAAAAAAU/66kkgUWtIzY/s1600/phobos.jpg

The God of Fear and Nekon. Notice any similarities?

Marvel and DC imitating each other is nothing new, but what is more notable is the character-centric formula. For years fans have complained about "event fatigue" with one big battle coming after another and all claiming to have the same high stakes that will change the universe, but usually in their execution manage to fall flat (Secret Invasion, Final Crisis). Changing the scope of the story to focus and expand upon one single character instead of having a large mass of costumed heroes all clamoring for a moment in the spotlight allows for a more nuanced and heartfelt story. Just think of the wildly popular TV show Lost. Each episode focused on a single character, all the while expanding on the mysteries of the island. If "emotions" and "feelings" feel like strange words to describe a huge comic book even involving super heroes and villains fighting each other, then you are not alone. But it is that unique aspect - causing readers to "feel" instead of become over-stimulated by action sequences - that might be the saving grave of event books.

If Marvel can do what Lost and Blackest Night did, and that is introduce some fresh mythology for Thor and keep the story grounded on his character, then fans might be in for a treat when Fear Itself hits shelves. If anything, a change in the format of events is most definitely welcome.

And I will be damned if everyone who picks up a hammer doesn't wind up in a Thor-inspired costume just like a selection of fan-favorites all got a Lantern outfit.

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-MoLmpGyUI6Y/TWVMwkQTbCI/AAAAAAAAAA8/TKP0rMmpNxU/s1600/thumbnailCACFM0P9.jpg
Storm would look good in Thor's helmet, right?
One of these things is just like the other.

False Profit
02-23-2011, 08:04 PM
lol I think Captain America and Superman are the only two people to pick up one of them damn hammers and keep their outfit.

Marvel: The House of Ideas?

Earth-2 Superman
02-23-2011, 10:25 PM
and this is surprising how?

Jack Roller
02-23-2011, 10:38 PM
Blackest Night was Marvel Zombies.

Bobby Digital 2.0
02-23-2011, 10:53 PM
If you really want to point to Marvel ripping off Blackest Night (which is overrated) you'd only need look at Necrosha.

duckman returns
02-23-2011, 11:46 PM
Marvel always bites off of other people, especially from DC.

Earth-2 Superman
02-23-2011, 11:54 PM
Blackest Night was Marvel Zombies.

not really.

but it was an alternate earth. which in turn is a ripoff of DC.

JxXxR
02-24-2011, 12:00 AM
If you really want to point to Marvel ripping off Blackest Night (which is overrated) you'd only need look at Necrosha.


truth has been spoken here

onionknees
02-24-2011, 03:18 AM
Yeah Necrosha was rip-off no question. Made even worse just how awful it was. But I don't think Blackest Night went all that well. It started off great, but fizzled out towards the end. At least to me it did.

False Profit
02-24-2011, 06:01 AM
soooo.... how long do you guys think it'll be before DC does a Vampire related crossover? lol

gdatruth
02-24-2011, 07:32 AM
No idea's original, there's nothin new under the sun
It's never what you do, but how it's done



NaS Lot

Dr Doom
02-24-2011, 07:39 AM
No idea's original, there's nothin new under the sun
It's never what you do, but how it's done
NaS Lot

Pretty much, but if Necrosha is any indication this is still not looking good, lol.

Jack Roller
02-24-2011, 12:42 PM
not really.

but it was an alternate earth. which in turn is a ripoff of DC.

When I hear Zombie Ronnie talking in Blackest Night it reminds me of Marvel Zombies. And not just a little bit. But the only reason I even bother saying it is because pointing out that a story in comics not being original could be done every Wednesday over and over. Originality is overrated. It's how you tell the story that matters. Marvel Zombies was a bit of a goof but an entertaining read. Blackest Night was obviously more serious but you have the same shit happening - what seems to be undead heroes acting like assholes and causing the living heroes a lot of grief. I liked Blackest Night better but not because of its supposed originality. And I'm sure if one of us nerds dug deeper we would find out Marvel Zombies wasn't original either. But obviously some people will have Marvel Zombies as their favorite. And of course Dip will have Necrosha as hers. And that's okay because I love the pictures of nekkid chicks with guns she keeps posting.

Jack Roller
02-24-2011, 12:44 PM
No idea's original, there's nothin new under the sun
It's never what you do, but how it's done



NaS Lot I lost for not seeing this before I posted.

odeisel
02-28-2011, 05:04 PM
lol I think Captain America and Superman are the only two people to pick up one of them damn hammers and keep their outfit.

Marvel: The House of Ideas?

That's becasue Thor himself relaxed the enchantment for them. They weren't "worthy" of the hammer